What’s in the Oven?

Choose any of these delicious Everyday Pies in one of many fresh fruit flavors. Want a special custom made pie? You can upgrade it to a specialty Detailed Message Pie for a $10. bump up price.
Order now and pay later. COD at the time of your Heather’s Pie pick-up.

Apple Pie – $38.00

Who doesn’t love the Classic Apple Pie? It’s #1 on the charts. Made from scratch, just like Grandpa used to make.

Apple Raspberry Pie – $40.00

The classic apple pie with a twist. Organic apples and fresh raspberries combine to make a delectable treat.

Blackberry Pie – $38.00

Picked fresh, shipped directly to Heather. Carefully using the sweetest organic berries to be baked inside a buttery flaky crust.

Blueberry Pie – $38.00

Fresh Wild Maine Blueberries baked to bubbly perfection in our award winning buttery flaky crust.

Bumble Pie – $40.00

Blackberries, blueberries, strawberries and raspberries mingle together to create this memorable tasting pie. This is the one repeatedly asked for.

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie – $36.00

Fresh organic rhubarb & strawberries fill this classic treat, served in a buttery flaky crust. Offered all year long.


We are donating $1.00 per pocket pie to our local Susan Lindgren Elementary School towards the Children’s Breakfast & Lunch Fund.

Order NOW

Cherry Cherry Pie – $36.00

Cherries and cherries galore. Heather’s take on this classic pie includes loads of 2 types of organic cherries baked a buttery flaky crust.

Peach Blueberry Pie – $36.00

Fresh organic blueberries and peaches come together in a buttery flaky pie crust.

Sweet & Savory Tart – $42.00

Give your tastebuds a ‘wake up call’ with these tarts made with a selection of seasonal organic vegetables. Were always open to 3 vegetables of your choice as well.

Slab Pie – $58.00

Deliciously luscious fresh organic fruit Slab Pies with many flavors to choose from. Made with our buttery crust or your choice of crusts.GF bumps up the fee $4. Serves 12-16.

Triple Berry Pie – $44.00

This one takes time to create. Fresh blackberries, blueberries, and raspberries mingle together with it’s adorable sweetly made top crust just for you.

Key Lime – $36.00

Freshly squeezed key-lime curd mixed and topped with fresh light fluffy cream, in a nut crust or a graham cracker crust.

Apple Cranberry Pecan Oatmeal Crisp Crumble Pie – $40.00

This one is my mother’s favorite – an apple, cranberry, and pecan filled pie covered with an organic oatmeal and brown sugar to make this crumble and baked in a buttery flaky crust.

Organic Fruit Tart – $42.00

The Custard first, Add your favorite two choices of Organic Fruit to this delicious buttery & flaky crust.

Peach Pie – $36.00

This is the baby that started it all. Fresh organic peaches layered in buttery flaky pie crust creates this award-winning pie

heather's pies menu

Order a Pie Online

Order Pie Crust
Order Pie Dough