Our Reviews

“Amazing qualities pies!!!! Picked up my 1st one today and oh my goodness, wow and yum! Heather was also amazing to talk to and learn that she really puts her heart in making the best pies. We even got to talking about making keto pies and I’m filled with the excite!”
– Anna Banana

“We ordered a key lime pie for my husbands birthday! It was beautiful and a huge hit! The beat we have ever had!!!”
– Hannah Rinehart

“We ordered a Key Lime pie for a birthday dinner. I ordered it on Friday at noon for a Saturday dinner. It was amazingly delicious and a work of art. I highly recommend!”
– Heidi Schachtman

“Heather’s pies are made fresh for your order. They are beautiful.”
– Becky Bystrom

“The best key lime pie I’ve had! Heather took my order on short notice and had it ready to go for a birthday celebration. Blew my expectations out of the water. Would recommend Heather any day!”
– Macy Henningsen

“Homemade pies, made from scratch. Fantastic!!!”
– Michael Meredith

“Seriously the best pie you could ever have anywhere.”
– John Kienzle

“Heather’s absolutely beautiful and delicious Key Lime pie was the perfect ending to my annual New Year’s luncheon. When I told my friends that I had discovered Heather’s Pies online and that all of her reviews were 5-star, my friend Mary said, “Well, I give her 6-stars!”
– Judy Rieckhoff

“For my son’s birthday he requested a key lime pie which is hard to come by in October but Heather came through! And it was the best key lime pie we’ve ever had. My son even said “it taste like she baked it with love”. Seriously yummy. Can’t wait to order from her again.”
– Michele Quattrin

“Absolutely love Heather and her pies! As usual, Heather makes everything from the crust to the whipped cream from scratch. Cream pies can often eat heavy, but Heather used her mad skills to create a light, airy version that has more depth of flavor thanks to the chocolate ganache than any coconut cream pie I’ve ever had. This is a new pie on her menu and I’m confident it’ll be a big hit!”
– Matthew Erickson

“Heather makes some amazing pies! We have ordered a few for various holidays, they have always been delicious and everyone wants to take a picture before we dig in. A definite goto whenever we want to impress, or just be impressed ourselves.”
– Mark G

Heather’s Pies offers some of the most divine pies under the sun. Not only are you working with someone who truly has a passion for their craft but the pies undoubtedly taste as good as they look. Whether you are buying it for yourself, for family or for a group and special occasions, you won’t regret buying one of these pies.”
– Mythomantic

“Wow. Simply delicious. Where has this banana cream pie been my whole life.”
– Jeannine Burnette

“The most delicious pie and work of art! Will be ordering again!”
– Stacy Doyle

Heather is as amazing as her pies!
– Kim McMahon-Gumm